Pages

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Out Stealing Horses by Per Petterson


Well, this one left me feeling cheated!  I was cheated out of Trond’s adult life. I was cheated out of so many details. From the time he and his mother went to Sweden to pick up the money until he showed up at the cabin, only bits of his life were given.  Maybe that was the point.  Did I really need to know all the details to understand the man?  I will admit I went online to read other reviews to see if I had missed something. Some left me wondering if we were talking about the same book!  Next I found a list of discussion questions for book clubs and began to realize I may have cheated myself from just enjoying the novel and his vivid attention to detail.  Being here in Florida I also discussed it with visiting friends. The more I talked about it the more I realized it was not such a bad book, I just wanted more!  It was like the season finale of Downton Abbey—how can it be over and when can I see more?
With my husband being one quarter Norwegian and one quarter Swedish, one would think I would know more about how these men like to keep things to pertinent facts only.  BTW—the other half is Scots/German!  Most of the family in Minnesota might relate to this book better than I!  They love their cold, their woods and their remoteness. They are also among the most loving people I know.  Trond seemed to be both even though he fought it.  His coming to the woods to have time to think was a return to what he had known as a child.  He had been as happy there as I think he could be. 
What an upbringing.  He spent so much time with his father who appeared to love him but then abandoned the family.  He learned so many things about survival from his father yet, I am not certain he loved his father—or his mother, his first wife, his children or maybe even the dog!  I think he was afraid to show his love for fear of losing what he loved.  The story developed because he had lost his wife and sister within a year’s span.  One thinks it is about mourning their loss but the whole story is about his friend, his father and his youth.  I think the mourning began long before his wife and sister died.
Thinks I found interesting:
Out Stealing Horses was both the game played by Jon and Trond and the code used by the Resistance for getting things between Norway and Sweden.  Maybe his father was instrumental in getting the heavy water secrets out.
Jon’s mother worked in the Resistance alongside Trond’s father and I do believe that when his father left the family it had something to do with an affair the two had developed and continued after the war but we know that she stayed on the farm until Jon returned and claimed his primogeniture right to the place.  Did his father abandon her as well?
Trond’s father left the telling of his story to another man, Franz.  Was this because he did not think he could share such details with a teenage son? Was it because he was gone before Trond reached adulthood and never had the opportunity to tell him personally. 
Lars and Trond end up at the same place and help each other out when necessary but both are men seeking solitude from early life. Lars felt betrayed by Jon who left after the death of Odd. He had stayed, endured the isolated childhood as the one who killed his twin, worked the farm and lost it due to laws beyond his control.
Trond spoke very little of his mother but the ending I did not see coming. It was as though they were happy once relieved of all ties with the father.
Things I still wanted to know:
Why would his father leave the family money knowing they could not take it out of Sweden?  And why leave so little that it probably cost as much to get there as was left?
What did Trond do for his life’s work that he had given up when he came to the cabin?  If he was a successful businessman then why live such a bare life?  Was that to reflect the desire to reclaim control over his life or was he truly thinking he was an old man (67 is hardly old and those Scandinavians life to be very old!) who had come to the woods to live out a short life?
Would Trond develop a better relationship with Ellen?  She had driven all the way out to find her father who barely had a relationship with her to begin with.  Was it her mother who died or was she the child of the first wife? 
Would Lars and he become friends and finally find some peace to ease their souls?
My take on the rest of the book!
Trond comes to terms with his life and even though he loves the solitude and the time to read Dickens realizes that he does not want to be his father. Trond uses his newfound lease on life to fix up the cabin, welcomes his daughter (s) and helps Lars realize that he was not at fault for killing Odd.  He has determined that he is indeed the leading character in his own life and chooses to life that life as he would have liked his to be.  Yes—the hopeless romantic here!
Enjoy all—see you in April.